In Seville’s Triana neighbourhood, I experienced the very essence of flamenco: a moment when music, dance and emotion became one.
In mid-November 2025, I visited Seville for the third time. It was a rather ambitious trip – exactly the sort I like. In just a few days, I managed to squeeze in southern Portugal, Gibraltar, Córdoba and Seville. I already knew the city, and my only real plan was to enjoy the view from the rooftop of the Querencia de Sevilla hotel.
I was given a truly beautiful room. It looked straight out over Plaza de San Francisco, the town hall, the bank building and two enormous Indian laurel trees with perfectly squared-off crowns. I hadn’t even opened my suitcase when I heard a familiar sound: heels striking the ground in rhythm. Someone was dancing flamenco literally beneath my window.
I liked what I saw, though I’m not sure whether it was the dancing, the music or the entire setting of the old square that appealed to me most. In my imagination, I’d already brought the entire cast of Carmen onto that square. After all, the opera’s first act takes place in a square in Seville, too. But I have to admit something: what made the moment particularly special for me was the fact that I was watching it all from the comfort of my hotel room.
At the time, I thought of flamenco as another of Seville’s tourist products, and I was convinced that watching this performance meant I’d genuinely experienced it. In fact, I was rather pleased with myself. I’d had the good fortune to get the whole thing for absolutely nothing, while foolish tourists were paying good money for expensive flamenco shows.
The fool was me.
Exactly one year later, I was back in Seville. This time I wasn’t alone. I’d come to a conference with a colleague and, as far as work allowed, successfully played the part of her personal tour guide. How successful I actually was is another story.
Tickets for the Alcázar were sold out, it was raining, and we’d already spent an hour in a queue trying to get tickets for the cathedral, at least. My colleague decided to take matters into her own hands and struck up a conversation with a rather resourceful tourism worker, who I was quite certain was selling her a load of nonsense.
She came away from that conversation with two tickets for a flamenco performance in Triana, a neighbourhood where, according to her new friend, even the stray cats practically dance flamenco.
At €28 a head, on a rainy day like that, it actually struck me as a sound investment.
Carmen – Act Two
A year earlier, with flamenco playing below my window, my imagination had staged the first act of Carmen in Plaza de San Francisco. Now it had apparently grown even more ambitious. In my head, our €28 tickets had bought us a place at Lillas Pastia’s tavern, from the second act of the same opera.
I pictured an old Andalusian tavern, a few wooden tables, wine and tapas, with a guitarist and dancers somewhere nearby. There might be a toreador or two, and of course the irresistible Carmen, approaching me to the rhythm of a seguidilla and offering me a glass of manzanilla.
I’m exaggerating a little, but I’ve seen Carmen often enough to have a fairly clear picture of a traditional Andalusian evening, with myself very much part of it.
There was, however, one rather serious problem. Nobody had promised me Carmen or manzanilla. Nobody had promised a tavern, dinner or tapas, either. I’d been promised flamenco, and flamenco was what I got.
And I didn’t need a single thing more.
From a Tavern to a Caseta
It had been an exhausting day. We’d walked more than 28,000 steps and simply had no energy left for the walk to Triana. Our Uber dropped us on Calle Pagés del Corro, right outside Flamenco El Real.
Instead of the Lillas Pastia tavern I’d imagined, there were rows of chairs facing a small stage, red-and-white stripes and paper lanterns hanging overhead. My first thought was: what on earth is this nonsense? Once again, though, the fool turned out to be me.
Our hosts showed us around and explained the thinking behind the décor. Flamenco El Real is designed to resemble a caseta, one of the distinctive fairground tents that go up around Seville for the Feria de Abril. The paper lanterns that had puzzled me on arrival are called farolillos, and they’re an essential part of the Seville fair. Someone had clearly put a lot of thought into it.
We were among the first to arrive, so we managed to claim the best seats in the front row.
Two drinks arrived, and I was no longer entirely sure what to expect. Actually, I ought to correct myself about something. I did get my manzanilla after all. It had simply married Sprite and become a rebujito.
Flamenco: A Conversation I Wasn’t Supposed to Understand – But Did
Onto the stage came a guitarist (tocaor), a singer (cantaor), a male dancer (bailaor) and a female dancer (bailaora). Four people, without particularly elaborate scenery or anything that might distract from their performance. First it was the sound of the guitar that caught my attention, then the singer’s voice, and finally the rhythm the dancers created by striking their shoes against the floor and clapping their hands. Everything was far more intense than the street performances I’d seen before. Not just louder, but somehow more complete.
The female dancer was excellent. Her movements struck me as precise, elegant and controlled. She wore an enormous white dress in which simply avoiding getting tangled up would have been an achievement, never mind dancing. And just to be clear, that was my colleague’s assessment, not mine.
I, however, was completely captivated by the male dancer.
I could list his movements, the speed at which his heels struck the floor, the positions of his arms and the way he followed the rhythm. But that would describe what he was doing, not why his performance stayed with me. This man, or so it seemed to me, felt every sound. His expression changed with the music, his arms followed its shifts, and even when he brought his body to a complete standstill, it felt as though the dance was carrying on somewhere inside him.
At one point, I caught myself trying to work out who was actually following whom. The guitarist following the dancer, or the dancer following the guitarist? Sometimes it seemed as though the guitar was inviting a movement and the dance was answering. Then the dancer would take the lead and the guitarist would adapt to him. There was something almost intimate about the exchange, a kind of conversation in which each understood perfectly what the other was trying to say.
And between them was a voice.
The singer’s voice was neither polished nor gentle. He sang with force, at times almost roughly, but it was precisely that rawness that made his singing so expressive. I couldn’t understand the words, yet I never felt I was missing anything essential. His voice seemed to carry an entire range of emotions, from sadness and longing to something I can only really call defiance.
Sometimes it was the voice that set the exchange in motion. The guitar would pick up the emotion and the dancer would turn it into movement. Then he’d stamp out a rhythm with his shoes and the others would follow his lead. They listened and responded to one another, as though they were speaking a language I didn’t know but somehow understood.
At certain moments I could no longer tell where the music ended and the dance began.
Five Minutes to Remember
The performance lasted exactly an hour. Filming wasn’t allowed for the first fifty-five minutes, but the organisers made an exception for the final five. I have to admit, I particularly liked that approach.
We live in a time when almost all of us lead a second, parallel life on social media alongside our real one. We travel, visit landmarks, go to concerts and performances, and spend at least some of that time thinking about the photographs and videos we’ll take home or share with others.
I took advantage of those last five minutes and filmed the finale. It gave me a memory I can watch again, while the preceding fifty-five minutes gave me one that no recording could ever capture.
Goosebumps from Lisbon
I can’t remember the exact moment during the performance when they began. I just know I felt goosebumps. The real kind, the ones that appear almost unnoticed and then spread through your body, making you forget everything else for a moment. Goosebumps that, for me, are a sure sign of genuine art.
And suddenly I was back in Lisbon.
It’s evening. I’m sitting in one of the traditional fado houses in Bairro Alto, with a glass of wonderful port in my hand. The heavy scent of a woman’s perfume suddenly fills the room. A few moments later, a lady walks past me. A lady in every sense of the word.
The guitars begin to play. The lady begins to sing. And I’m covered in goosebumps more powerful than almost any I’ve ever felt.
It was Lenita Gentil, one of Portugal’s great fado singers, with a voice of extraordinary power and depth. I can no longer remember every song she performed that evening, but there’s one I’ve never forgotten: Hasta siempre, Comandante. I can still hear the way she sang the refrain, especially its final words: “Comandante Che Guevara.” Curiously, of everything I heard that evening, the song I remember most clearly was the one in Spanish.
Lenita wasn’t simply singing. At least, that wasn’t how I experienced her performance. There was something about the way she pronounced the words, paused between the verses and allowed the emotion to come through in her voice. I felt as though I wasn’t listening to someone performing a song, but to a woman telling me about her own life. About something she’d loved, lost or perhaps never had in the first place. Somehow, I felt I understood what lay behind her words.
What Lenita Gentil expressed with her voice in Lisbon, the dancer expressed with his movements in Triana. And yet I experienced them in almost exactly the same way.
When something affects me that deeply, I often can’t stop thinking about it. I look for an explanation, as though I’m unwilling to accept that there are things we understand perfectly well but struggle to put into words.
Searching for an explanation for what I’d experienced in Lisbon and Seville, I came across the idea of duende. Federico García Lorca used it to describe that elusive force in an artistic performance, something that doesn’t come simply from skill or flawless technique.
Was what I experienced that evening duende? I don’t know. I’m not even sure there’s a reliable way to answer that question. All I know is that it wasn’t merely the performers’ skill that moved me.
A year earlier, I’d watched flamenco from my hotel window and felt rather smug about getting it for free. I was convinced I’d seen everything flamenco had to offer. It took a year and a ticket bought almost by accident to realise just how wrong I’d been.
You don’t watch flamenco from a window. You go to it, take a seat in the front row and wait for it to find you.
And for those €28, I got something I hadn’t even known I was looking for.