Both are Della Scala castles, the work of the family that ruled medieval Verona, and both make an easy outing from the city. They're very different visits, though. Sirmione's Scaligero Castle stands in Lake Garda, with water in its moat and a 37-metre keep you can climb. The state runs it, it stays open through the middle of the day, and in summer it is packed. Soave's castle sits on a hill above a small walled town in Verona's province. It's smaller and much quieter, and you can see it in about an hour, as long as you don't arrive during its long lunch closing.

Short answer: pick Sirmione if you want the lake and don't mind crowds. Go to Soave if you'd rather have a medieval town nearly to yourself, especially on the third Sunday of the month, when an antiques market fills its two main streets. Neither castle opens on a Monday, so plan around that whichever you choose.

This comparison draws on three TravelFeed trip reports: two by @hotspotitaly, who lives near Soave and wrote about both its castle and its market in 2022, and one by @katrin-lux, who visited Sirmione's castle and wrote it up in 2020. Opening hours and prices come from each castle's own published information.

The two castles at a glance

The Della Scala, or Scaligeri, ruled Verona and much of the surrounding area in the 13th and 14th centuries, and they fortified the territory they held. Soave and Sirmione are two of the castles they left behind. Soave's looks down over a walled town. Sirmione's controls the way into an old town at the tip of a narrow peninsula on Lake Garda.

For Soave, the regional tourism portal run by the Veneto region says Cansignorio della Scala "had the merit of restoring and enlarging the castle". He also walled the town and built its Hall of Justice and Scaliger Palace. Parts of the castle are older than that. The portal dates a small three-apse church in the first courtyard probably to the 10th century and describes a fresco of the Virgin Mary on the gate tower dated 1321. The outermost courtyard came later, added by the Republic of Venice in the 15th century. @hotspotitaly gives 1379 as the year Cansignorio built the castle and says that a noble family from the area bought it in the late 1800s and restored it.

Sirmione's history is cleaner on paper. The Italian Ministry of Culture, which runs the castle, dates it to the second half of the 14th century and says the architecture points to Cansignorio and Antonio II della Scala, around 1360 to 1380. Under Napoleon and later Austria it was an armoury and barracks. The restoration that gave it its current look began in 1919. (Older accounts, @katrin-lux's included, credit Mastino I della Scala in the 13th century. The Ministry's dating is the one to go by.)

A square stone castle tower with swallowtail battlements rising from turquoise water, with a wooden drawbridge connecting it to a battlemented wall
Sirmione's Scaligero Castle is a water castle: the moat is part of Lake Garda, and you cross drawbridges to reach the inner courtyard. Photo by @katrin-lux

What a visit to Soave Castle is like

Soave announces itself before you reach the castle. As @hotspotitaly wrote in 2022, the first thing that strikes you on arrival is the height of the medieval walls, with the castle above on the hill, both still intact. You enter the town through Porta Verona and walk up from the centre. The regional portal says the castle can be reached on foot from Piazza dell'Antenna in the old town, or by car on the road that climbs from the north side.

In his write-up of the castle, @hotspotitaly notes that he hadn't been inside since he was 15, even though he lives nearby. Visitors usually come in through a small entrance cut into the walls. The main gate with the drawbridge is almost always closed, he says, though the regional portal describes the north side, across the drawbridge, as the main entrance.

A grassy path inside high battlemented brick and stone walls leading to an arched gate tower, with hills in the background
Inside Soave's walls, looking towards one of the castle's gate towers, with the hills behind. Photo by @hotspotitaly

Inside there are two courtyards. The first holds the remains of the small church. In the second, a staircase climbs to the wall walk and on to the keep. Next to it is the house of the captain who ran the castle and the defence of the valley. When @hotspotitaly visited, the captain's house, with its period furnishings and armour, was closed because of Covid rules. Check whether it has reopened before you count on seeing it.

A stone building with green shutters and an external white stone staircase in a castle courtyard, with people standing on the battlements above
The second courtyard at Soave, with the staircase that leads up towards the wall walk. Photo by @hotspotitaly

The keep has the darkest story here. According to @hotspotitaly, it was used as a prison, people condemned to death were thrown from the top, and many skeletons were found at its base. It's a small site. He puts the visit at about an hour and suggests pairing it with the walk up from the town below.

A tall brick tower with battlements and an Italian flag on top, beside a walled castle courtyard in late-afternoon sun
Soave's keep, which according to @hotspotitaly once served as the castle's prison. Photo by @hotspotitaly

What a visit to Sirmione Castle is like

Sirmione is a water castle. The Ministry's description, and @katrin-lux's 2020 report, both stress how it controls the way into the old town at the tip of the peninsula. She describes wide, deep moats, a mix of fired brick and natural stone, and swallowtail battlements on the outer walls. Inside, the battlements change to a saddle shape around the courtyard and the harbour basin.

Her route is a useful map. The entrance is on the right as you approach. You cross a small stone bridge to the ticket desk, turn right into the main courtyard, and from there you can reach underground vaulted passages. Opposite the ticket office, two drawbridges in a row lead into the core of the castle. Stairs from the inner courtyard go up to the walls and corner towers. The Ministry says the wall walks run around all four sides of the main courtyard and cross the three corner towers. The 37-metre keep is included in the ticket, and @katrin-lux rates its view over the peninsula and the harbour as the best in the castle.

The one part you can't just walk into is the dock, the darsena. When @katrin-lux visited, she couldn't get in. The Ministry now says it can be visited on guided tours only, and calls it the only surviving 14th-century fortified port of its kind. It reopened to the public in March 2018 after restoration.

Crowds: the biggest difference

This is where the two part ways. @katrin-lux calls Sirmione's castle one of the most beautiful on Lake Garda and says it was "teeming with tourists". She went around midday and into the afternoon, which she describes as peak time, in alleys she calls very narrow. Her advice is to go in the morning or the evening instead. Bring sunscreen too. The first stretch of the old town past the castle is lined with ice cream parlours and souvenir shops, she writes, but it thins out after a few minutes, and the side alleys are where to escape the crush.

The Soave reports don't mention crowds at all. @hotspotitaly's photos of the castle show only a handful of people in the courtyards on a clear day. If fighting for space on a battlement would spoil the day, that's a point for Soave.

Soave's third-Sunday antiques market

Soave has one big draw Sirmione can't match: its antiques market. It's held on the third Sunday of every month along the town's two main streets. @hotspotitaly goes for used books, which he says sometimes include rarities and out-of-print titles. His wife goes for vintage clothes. He also watched a man buy a candlestick for 150 euros and call it a great deal. The market runs practically all day, he says, but that depends on the weather. When it turns bad, traders tend to pack up after noon.

People in winter coats browsing tables of second-hand books and records on a street in front of an ochre building
A used-book stall at Soave's antiques market, from @hotspotitaly's 2022 walk through it. Photo by @hotspotitaly

The castle is open on Sundays, so you can combine the two. Mind the lunch break, though. The castle closes from 12:00 to 15:00 in summer and from 12:00 to 14:00 in winter. On a fine day, a good order is the castle when it opens at 9:00, then down into town for the market. If the forecast is poor, do the market first, before the traders leave.

Opening hours and tickets

For Soave, the castle's own website says it's open Tuesday to Sunday and closed on Mondays. Summer hours are 9:00 to 12:00 and 15:00 to 18:00. Winter hours are 9:00 to 12:00 and 14:00 to 16:00. The site doesn't publish its season dates, but the Veneto region's listing gave April to September for the summer timetable in 2024. It also listed a Friday-to-Sunday-only spell in January and February 2025, so winter visitors should check before going. Entry is paid, but neither site lists a price.

At Sirmione, the Ministry of Culture's page gives Tuesday to Sunday, 8:30 to 19:15, closed on Mondays and on 1 January and 25 December. The ticket office shuts 45 minutes before closing. A full ticket is €10. EU nationals aged 18 to 25 pay €2, and under-18s go free. A €20 combined ticket also covers the Grottoes of Catullus, the Sirmione Archaeological Museum and the Villa Romana in Desenzano. The page's visitor information says booking is required for groups and schools.

Getting there from Verona

Soave is on the A4 motorway, which has a Soave exit. Without a car, @hotspotitaly says the nearest railway station is San Bonifacio, about 5 km away, and a bus runs from there to the town. Check the bus times before you set off, because the castle's lunch closing makes an early arrival the safest choice.

Sirmione is off State Road 11, with its own exit on the A4. The castle is inside the pedestrian zone, so the Ministry advises parking in one of the paid car parks on the edge of town and walking in. By rail, take the train to Desenzano del Garda and then the SIA bus to Sirmione's historic centre.

For more first-hand reports from around the country, see TravelFeed's Italy destination page.

FAQ

Is Soave Castle worth visiting?

Yes, if you like your castles uncrowded and don't need a big site. It's small, and @hotspotitaly puts the visit at about an hour. It works best combined with the walled town below, and better still on the third Sunday of the month, when the antiques market is on.

Can you visit Sirmione Castle or Soave Castle on a Monday?

No. Both are closed on Mondays. Sirmione's castle is also closed on 1 January and 25 December.

How long do you need at Sirmione Castle?

The Ministry doesn't give a visit length. The courtyard, the wall walks and the climb up the 37-metre keep are all included in a standard ticket, and the dock needs a separate guided tour. Allow extra time for the old town beyond the castle, and go early or late in the day if you can. @katrin-lux found midday to afternoon the busiest time.

When is the Soave antiques market?

On the third Sunday of every month, along the two main streets of the old town. According to @hotspotitaly, it runs most of the day in good weather, but traders often leave after noon if the weather turns.